Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 16th November 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Holyrood cash props up Mugabe



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 10 August 2008
THE Scottish Parliament pension fund is helping to prop up the regime of Zimbabwean dictator Robert Mugabe, Scotland on Sunday can reveal.
More than £18m has been invested on behalf of MSPs, hundreds of thousands of which has gone into firms which have already been criticised for their close links to the failed African state. The companies involved include Anglo-American, the mining giant which is investing $400m (£208m) to develop a platinum mine in Zimbabwe.

Prime Minister Gordon Brown recently warned the firm that it should think again about "supporting" the Mugabe regime in this way. And Conservative leader David Cameron has called on all companies and individuals with "any dealings" in Zimbabwe to ensure that they are not keeping Mugabe in power.

But figures released by the Scottish Parliament show that MSPs have invested more than £100,000 in Anglo-American via the pension fund. There are also substantial investments in other companies heavily involved in the country, including Standard Chartered bank, Rio Tinto, Barclays and Royal Dutch Shell. On the back of these and other investments, the MSPs' fund grew by £700,000 last year.

The revelations come weeks after several MSPs backed the decision to strip Mugabe of his knighthood and called on the international community to redouble their efforts to bring about change in the country.

Last night, one senior MSP on the Scottish Parliament Corporate Body (SPCB) – its ruling council – said the revelation was "regrettable" and he would examine whether it was possible to switch the money.

Mike Pringle said: "It is extremely regrettable that the Scottish Parliament has to be involved in investing in Zimbabwe. I would be hopeful that as a Corporate Body we would be able to influence this decision.

"As a member of the Corporate Body I will be suggesting that they discuss this with Baillie Gifford (their investment managers] to find out whether there is any flexibility in the way it is managed."

Senior Nationalist MSP Roseanna Cunningham said: "I have no idea how it's funded or invested in that sense but, like most MSPs, I would be pretty concerned."

The MSPs' scheme requires them to pay in 6% of their £54,000 salary each year. In return they get back a generous one-50th of their final salary for each year at Holyrood.

Adam Ramsay, Ethical Investment campaigner and president of Edinburgh University Students' Association, said: "By investing in a company, the Scottish Parliament is giving both financial and moral support to what the company is doing. You can't condemn something with one hand if you are paying for it with the other."

Along with Anglo-American, Barclays has attracted the greatest controversy for its Zimbabwean operations. It owns two-thirds of Barclays Bank Zimbabwe, and contributes to a government loan scheme that is thought to have lent money to at least five ministers for farm improvements. Standard Chartered operates in a similar manner. Rio Tinto, another mining giant, has a diamond mine at Murowa.

A spokeswoman for the Scottish Parliament said: "The Members' Pension Scheme is part of a pooled fund... which operates in accordance with the United Nation's Principles for Responsible Investment.

"Our total investment in this fund would have to be worth more than £50m in order for MSPs to be able to direct the investments."

Anglo-American claimed last night that withdrawing investment from its activities in Zimbabwe would only make things worse in the ravaged country.

"Anglo-American is deeply concerned about the current political situation in Zimbabwe and condemns the violence and human rights abuses that are taking place," it said. "The responsible development of the Unki mine will create a long-term viable business which will be important to the economic future of Zimbabwe for years to come."

Another Nationalist MSP, Bill Wilson, has written to Zimbabwean opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai expressing his concern that "such investments might be serving to perpetuate Robert Mugabe's despotic regime".

The Parliament's Fund has previously attracted controversy after it emerged it also invested in British America Tobacco – despite having voted through a ban on smoking in public places.

Mugabe and Tsvangirai on brink of power deal

The full article contains 696 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 10 August 2008 12:46 AM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: Zimbabwe
 
1

,

10/08/2008 00:07:14
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

subrosa,

10/08/2008 00:12:18
No mention of the fact the Westminster government haven't halted the building of a new British embassy in Harare. I believe it's nearly completed. Double standards as usual from the Scotsman's Sunday paper.
3

The McKellarator,

10/08/2008 00:17:11
I wonder what the Johnson Press pension is invested in?
4

Soup kitchen,

10/08/2008 00:19:09
At least Alex Salmond and the SNP don't also write to him to explore closer relations on common interests.
5

muppetfinder,

10/08/2008 00:36:18
most peopel don't know where there pension fund is invested. The Scotsman just has to have a go at SNP since labour isn't. wonder when SNP are going to bite back and trash Johnston Press
6

The McKellarator,

10/08/2008 00:46:57
No need to muppetfinder, they're haemorrhaging readers on a daily basis.


So we're talking about £100k invested in a company who've been in Zim for the past 60 years. Gosh, wonder who is on the board?

http://tinyurl.com/6ywo25
7

Castaway,

10/08/2008 01:11:37
The Scottish Parliament pension fund has company.
The Greens say KCC (Kent County Council) has a total of £109.5 million invested in companies it claims has a link with Zimbabwe.These are mining groups Anglo American and Rio Tinto, oil giants BP and Shell and banks Standard Chartered and Barclays.26/07/2008
The Sunday Tribune (Ireland)has learned that the State's National Pension Reserve Fund (NPRF) has invested over €578m in a variety of Zimbabwe-based companies.July 8th, 2008
Greater Manchester Pension Fund-Anglo American,Barclays,Standard Charter, Rio Tinto, Nestle and British American Tobacco etc (All have Zimbabwe connections).
The 440 billion Danish crown, second pillar pension scheme, ATP, is mulling over its investments in mining company Anglo American because of its presence in Zimbabwe.
8

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 10/08/2008 01:20:31

Its long been known, "Pension Funds" are a 'Ripp-Off"

Anyone that contributes to them are foolish, much better to invest your money into property, even though the 'slump' is with us.

I knew this over 20years ago! put your money into a pension fund, better fling it away!
9

baffies away,

10/08/2008 01:20:35
Its at best, an interesting article but, hardly headline material when there is the threat of all out war in Georgia. The headline deliberately states Holyrood which everyone knows these days implies the SNP. Good journalism spoiled by an editors political bias maybe, but, I used to expect better from the Scotsman group.

I am sure that 99% of people in the country have no idea exactly who their pension fund invests with, and while its correct that our elected representatives should have laid better rules governing their pensions, I find it hard to understand why this is the leader article when so much else is going on globally that should be a concern.
10

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 10/08/2008 01:24:44

#10,

The whole paper is absolutely rubbish today!

It is the worst edition ever!
11

Canadian Jambo,

10/08/2008 02:37:16
What the fecks going on here -all the nonsense about Liz Rawlings and Eaddie Barnes? There is an important issue at stake here. Why is no one discussing it?? Does someone have something to hide? Where are the normally voluble cybernats?
12

Canadian Jambo,

10/08/2008 02:40:11
What is going on here? This is a serious issue and all the Liz and Eddie postings are way off. Where are all the cybernats when you want to hear from them??
13

Canadian Jambo,

10/08/2008 03:00:34
(This is my third try.) What is this nonsense about Liz and Eddie?? This is a serious matter. Where are all the normally voluble cybernats?
14

Pender Paul,

Pender Island 10/08/2008 06:33:32
My pension comes from the British Columbia Teachers' Pension Fund. It has nearly $200 million Cdn. invested in Anglo American, Barclay's, Rio-Tinto and British American Tobacco. I have been trying for nearly ten years to have the pension plan adopt a set of principles to guide it in ethical investing. My own union refuses to seriously debate the subject. It leads me to believe that both my union and my pension plan provider place a higher value on profitability than on human rights and decency. Additionally, this is but another example of the absolute immorality of capitalism. We chastise our students for using a certain four letter word--in my opinion, all who use the word "profit" should have their mouths washed out with lye soap--for the sake of profit we are willing to push aside any notion of social justice. Shame.
15

scottishcoffindodgerno1,

Tram City 10/08/2008 07:55:23
The Mineworkers Pension Fund has oodles of cash.Gives me plenty every month,don't care where they invest.I need lots of money to spend on lots of GOODIES
16

Waus,

safety bay 10/08/2008 08:17:17
David Banks what a low life scum bag you'd be,Good on Ya Scotsman for bringing this story to lght the idea of having money invested in Mugabe's back yard is totally unacceptable he's a mass Murderer&despot/Tyrant thats a true fact.
17

1745,

Edinburgh 10/08/2008 08:53:07
What sort of deal was done that this newspaper was able to hack into Baillie Gifford's investment programme?
18

New kid on the blog,

BORDERS! 10/08/2008 09:28:42
7-1000
DAVID BANKS - YOU ARE ONE SICK PERSON. SEEK HELP.
19

donald,

glasgow 10/08/2008 10:26:58
Send Eddie Barnes to Zimbabwe and give Labour propaganda a rest.
20

brownlie,

10/08/2008 10:28:10
wtf
21

subrosa,

10/08/2008 10:37:24
# 7

Thanks for that explanation. It may have been an opportunity to mention the present building of the British embassy in Harare though. It's something that hasn't been in the headlines and the cost of it is rather excessive by all accounts.
22

Resolutions,

10/08/2008 13:06:36
For goodness sake! Who has taint their reason a' tegether? This makes a mockery of reasoned debate.

Surely, this is a lead for any newspaper investigative journalists(if there are any left) to dig deep and find out just who is investing in Zimbabwe? Should make very interesting reading.

Like most who are in pension schemes - and many had no choice - No idea where the money is invested. And there seems to be no easy route to find out either. Can you?
23

Jock 1O7,

10/08/2008 13:31:41
Does this have any connection with the Kalashnikov firing SNP councillor from Glasgow?
24

Jock 1O7,

10/08/2008 13:32:30
Does this have any connection with the Kalashnikov firing SNP councillor from Glasgow?
25

Stirling Sentinel,

Stirling 10/08/2008 13:39:39
What a very stupid and mismanaged site this is.
What the hell is wrong in that about 900 comments are "removed by Administrator" ?? If someone is deliberately blocking comment cannot Johnston Press do something about it .
26

Former_Zimbabwean,

Edinburgh 10/08/2008 14:45:29
I think this is a fair and worthwhile story. Economic forces, often hidden, drive a lot of what happens in the world. It's everyone's duty to find out where their investments go, as this article implies.

As far as I can see there is no party political bias here. You'll see that Bill Wilson, an SNP MSP, is credited with raising the issue. In fact, I suspect this story was triggered by his letter to Morgan Tsvangirai which you can read on his website (www.billwilsonmsp.org).
27

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 10/08/2008 15:41:39
As the author of this article must be more than well aware, the last published accounts of the Conservative and Labour Party show they both of them have substantial holdings in Anglo-American Mining and British-American Tobacco?

Therefore, both these politicial parties at Westminster are also propping up Robert Mugabe's regime!
28

Keith Lagden,

10/08/2008 16:30:20
Dictators Unite
29

Keith Lagden,

10/08/2008 16:30:25
Dictators Unite
30

Keith Lagden,

10/08/2008 16:30:44
Dictators Unite
31

Keith Lagden,

10/08/2008 16:30:47
Dictators Unite
32

grannie,

Glasgow 10/08/2008 16:58:21
True saying . It's an ill wind that doesn't blow someone some good. Two sides of the coin
33

the reporter,

Godalming, Surrey 10/08/2008 20:48:24
Another busy day for the admimistrator by the look of it !
34

Hugo of Garven,

10/08/2008 21:25:29
Don't get upset by the child who posted from 13 to 1000.

Eventually it will grow up. Unfortunately it might take many years.

As the Good Book says:-

C'est la vie, Jimmy.
35

getinnnn,

Scotland 10/08/2008 22:22:06
I'm going to make a bigger bolder X in the SNP selection box in the next election because of all of these kind of articles: How dare they try to spread dirt about true Scots i.e those who are not union jack,redcoat grovellers...
36

getinnnn,

Scotland 10/08/2008 22:23:12
I'm going to make a bigger bolder X in the SNP selection box in the next election because of all of these kind of articles: How dare they try to spread dirt about true Scots i.e those who are not union jack,redcoat grovellers...
37

getinnnn,

Scotland 10/08/2008 22:24:24
I'm going to make a bigger bolder X in the SNP selection box in the next election because of all of these kind of articles: How dare they try to spread dirt about true Scots i.e those who are not union jack,redcoat grovellers...
38

getinnnn,

Scotland 10/08/2008 22:25:15
I'm going to make a bigger bolder X in the SNP selection box in the next election because of all of these kind of articles: How dare they try to spread dirt about true Scots i.e those who are not union jack,redcoat grovellers...
39

getinnnn,

Scotland 10/08/2008 22:26:44
I'm going to make a bigger bolder X in the SNP selection box in the next election because of all of these kind of articles: How dare they try to spread dirt about true Scots i.e those who are not union jack,redcoat grovellers...
40

getinnnn,

Scotland 10/08/2008 22:27:37
I'm going to make a bigger bolder X in the SNP selection box in the next election because of all of these kind of articles: How dare they try to spread dirt about true Scots i.e those who are not union jack,redcoat grovellers...
41

Resolutions,

11/08/2008 16:42:49
It has taken long enough to 'fix' this!!

Has anyone found out yet, where their pension fund is invested?

Or indeed where any other 'investment type funds' are?

How do you find out this information?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.