Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 30th November 2008 Change Date

The Scotsman Digital Archive - Special Christmas Offer

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Crisis for the economy means peace for Labour



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 12 October 2008
AS A declaration of peace, it couldn't have been much plainer. When Labour MPs met last week for their first meeting at Westminster since returning from summer break, George Howarth, a former Home Office minister, got to his feet. Four months earlier, Howarth had told Brown bluntly that he was "the problem". Last month, he was among those calling for a leadership contest.
But in front of his colleagues, he was suddenly penitent: "It's time we got behind the Prime Minister. Hostilities are now over."

How things change. Some plotters had pencilled in last week as the moment Brown might be toppled, that another dire o
pinion poll would convince Cabinet ministers that this was the time to tell the Prime Minister the bad news. But the enormity of the financial crisis engulfing global markets has swept up all before it – including thoughts of a change of leader.

No wonder that last week Brown was walking a little lighter on his feet. For the first time since the SNP won the Glasgow East by-election in July, the Prime Minister was able to put to one side thoughts of his imminent political demise. The positive reception which was accorded the Government's rescue package on Tuesday added to his bonhomie.

He was even able to crack a joke that night. After someone's mobile rang during his after-dinner speech, he commented: "I don't know if another bank has fallen." The humour was of the gallows variety, but Brown's smile was genuine, not the fake 10-watt lightbulb variety he has taken to switching on and off at photo opportunities.

The past few days have also been good for Alistair Darling. Only a few weeks ago, the Chancellor was pilloried after he had declared that Britain was entering its worst economic period for 60 years. Insiders say the storm that followed his comments pushed Darling close to tears. But last week, his words appeared to be a modicum of understatement. Sixty years? What about ever?

The Chancellor's reputation was further enhanced by the revelation that, on Tuesday night, as a deal with the banks on a rescue package was being thrashed out, Brown had opted to go to bed and leave Darling in charge. And few were prepared to condemn Darling for having waited until Wednesday before unveiling his plan. "When you're talking about £500bn of public funds, you'd hope there'd be a bit of dither," said one Conservative.

It would stand to reason – with both Brown and Darling having enjoyed such happy times – that David Cameron has thus lost out. Certainly, the Tory leader's private view of two weeks ago that Brown would be out sooner rather than later looks incorrect. Cameron's worst moment was at Prime Minister's Questions on Wednesday when, after demanding the Government reign in lavish banking bonuses, Brown read out a quote from the week previously where Cameron had declared he would not make "cheap" digs about bankers. The manic order-paper waving of the Labour MPs afterwards revealed all the pent-up frustration they have built up over the summer while watching their own leader being mauled.

However, the Conservatives are sanguine this weekend, believing that, once the immediate crisis is over, attention will focus once again on how the mess was created in the first place. Cameron and shadow chancellor George Osborne will not be slow in reminding voters of Brown's record.

For Alex Salmond, however, the new landscape of British politics looks more daunting. With Iceland having flattened his "arc of prosperity", the First Minister has a tricky job to persuade voters that Scotland would have been better off on its own over the past two tumultuous weeks. Labour campaigners gathering in Glenrothes for next month's by-election now believe the game has changed and a new-found optimism is coursing through their veins. "Economy bust, Union saved," said one.

Glenrothes will undoubtedly give the first indication of how the economic storm is playing with the public. Should Labour hold the seat, an enticing question will once again hover before Brown – should he opt for an election next year? The best betting is that Brown and Darling will inflate public spending further next year to see off the coming recession. So why not go then, rather than wait for the inevitable cutbacks, now set for 2010? Some Labour MPs believe he will go to the country. "I've got June 2009 pencilled in," says one.

And a further reason presents itself. Next summer, the European elections are scheduled. If Brown's position is once again being questioned, and Labour do badly, he may well be forced to quit anyway. In other words, he might as well have his shot.





The full article contains 790 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 11 October 2008 8:21 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

ratzo,

12/10/2008 00:55:20
Yesterday's poll of polls in the Independent put the Tories on an outright majority of 108 seats so it's premature to talk of any Labour recovery.

The fallout of Labour's gross economic mismanagement hasn't yet reached the 'real' economy. When it does there will be a great number of unforgiving people who will view Brown & Darling with nothing remotely approaching equanimity. That is more likely to increase the Tory majority than lessen it.

So Barnes is right. Labour have nothing to lose by calling for a quick election before the true scale of the devastation hits the street. Its would be a cheap and sleazy trick, of course, and entirely transparent. Doubtless it is already being seriously considered. But at the end of the day, all that will be at stake is the size of the Tory majority in the next administration, nothing more. Labour are dead meat.
2

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 12/10/2008 09:56:14
It is interesting how the Tories have recoiled in horror and stepped back from this crisis hoping that Gordon Brown would self-destruct?

A few weeks ago Brown was down and almost counted out!

On the 9th bell he has risen like Lazarus! Gordon Brown, and Alistair Darling, would appear to relish being up to their necks in the brown stuff!

In recent weeks we have heard very little from David Cameron, George Osborne, and Nick Clegg, and the public silence has been almost deafening! At least Vince Cable, one of the P.M.'s most vociferous critics
has grudgingly praised the P.M. for his handling of these terrible events.

Journalists reported that after Cameron and Osborne met Brown and Darling to be briefed about the situation both emerged visibly shell-shocked and since have hardly contributed anything to the ongoing debate about the crisis. These slick Tory operators might be able to sell mobile phones to deaf mutes but as Brown so profoundly stated: this is no time for novices!

The Tories believed that this crisis would finish off Brown and New Labour but as events have clearly shown, so far it hasn't gone to plan.
3

Linda,

Edinburgh 12/10/2008 10:16:03
Lets never forget that it was Brown and Darling who caused the Banking Crisis in the first place
4

it has always been allan,

12/10/2008 18:02:55
Our Dear leader promised us an end to boom and bust and he has really succeeded with the fisrt part of the promise. Hope to read his retirement memoirs, actually as soon as possible.
5

Proximaking,

Stonehaven 12/10/2008 18:35:07
Given what is happening does anyone want to reassess their ideas of the old anti-christ scenario, wasn't he supposed to do what Gordon Brown is attempting to do? One world government is one small step behind one world financial solution. Is Gordon Brown the anti-christ? I think we should be told. Incidentally the "miracle economies" of West Germany and Japan only remained "miracle economies" for so long as the people at the top only "earned" approximately six times that of those at the bottom and they paid six times as much tax and took six times as much home, maybe Gordon should go the whole hog and demand the 666 solution. Funny how jokes have a way of becoming reality these days.
6

JCA REID,

Annan 13/10/2008 14:17:26
Brown has managed to deflect the mess we are in onto the Global stage. That is why he is a happier man now. "See it was nowt to do with me, but a global thingy!"
for a decade he built his "growth, no boom or bust, with prudence the watchword", on an ocean of debt & cheap money!
If there had been real economic growth this crisis would have been manged more easily instead of chucking billions at it. I have not heard of the Middle Eastern Banks, other European countries, outwith Iceland/France/Germany, reaching for the panic buttons. & as for the Asian Banks of Malaysia/Singapore/China.....
his "ersatz" economics, with money pouring into the governmnet coffers & an unparalleled rate & we're "bust"!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.