Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

The hunt is On.
Sponsored by
Can you track down Scotland's wildest beastie?

SOS Eligibles

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Teresa Hunter: Labour's promised tax cuts only exist in a virtual world



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 November 2008
LAST week's story about the divorce of a couple who met on Second Life must have been the kiss of death for the online virtual world.
Did you catch those pictures? Not exactly the stuff that dreams are made of. For readers who didn't see the stories, Second Life allows the, how shall we put it, visually challenged to act out a second life by pretending to be drop-dead gorgeous sup
ermen or women.

But now all their covers are blown, largely because one pug-ugly couple took the whole thing too far and got married, and then took it further still and got divorced. She said he was unfaithful to her, again on Second Life. Leopards, spots, change…

I'd never heard of this virtual world for sad losers before reading the story. As someone who has difficulty holding one life together, the thought of a second one has little appeal.

Many, though, welcome a second chance. Take Prime Minister Gordon Brown. He's enjoying a renaissance, charging round the world like Superman, single-handedly solving all the problems of the global economy. Yet his alter ego stumbles through Prime Minister's Question Time. Who brought in the Kryptonite?

And which one is promising us tax cuts? The one who won't stop at anything to save the world, or the other who dithers and obfuscates.

This weekend Brown has called on the world for co-ordinated tax cuts. Given our diverse systems of taxation it is hard to imagine what such an animal might look like, other than the horse which when designed by a committee ended up as a camel, bringing us back to Second Life.

In real life you have to kiss a lot of frogs, no disrespect to the French, before you meet your prince. But if I had to put money on it, I'm guessing Chancellor Alistair Darling will turn out to be more of a tax toad than a prince when he stands up to deliver his pre-Budget speech in just over a week. Leopards, spots, change…

The rhetoric will be full of slash and burn all right. But like many Labour Budgets, in all probability the detail will fall apart in our hands when examined in the cold light of day.

For example, personal allowances are in a mess after the Chancellor increased them by £600 in May as part of the adjustment over the 10p tax band. It was announced as a one-off, but as we said at the time, tax conventions do not permit allowances such as these, once added, to be removed.

So expect this to be continued after April but proclaimed as a tax giveaway, which it is not. The threshold for National Insurance could be raised to the same level, of £6,035, bringing relief to the lower paid.

Brown has already hinted that the planned increase in car tax, doubling the tax on many family cars, will be postponed, at least for cars bought before 2006. This too will be announced as a tax-cutting measure, which it is not.

There will be changes to tax credits, but as no one understands them, we'll never know if they are genuine cuts.

Darling should scrap stamp duty. Later this week the Council of Mortgage Lenders will report lending falling to unimaginable new lows. The property tax is producing no revenue, so should be ditched to kick-start the housing market, if only temporarily.

If they have any sense, they will boost tax breaks on savings. But as for 2p or 4p off the basic rate of tax, dream on. As Einstein said, tax is too difficult for mathematicians and should be left to philosophers. And what are philosophers if not dreamers?

Investors face delays

WE CONTINUE to be inundated with e-mails from investors with failed Edinburgh firm Cameron Farley, which is currently in provisional liquidation pending a court hearing to appoint Grant Thornton, prior to a wind-up.

Investors are understandably distraught that not only are their savings frozen, but no one will tell them what is happening, and when or if they will get their money back.

We have some bad news for them: they are extremely unlikely to hear anything significant, or certainly see any money before Christmas.

No date has been set for the hearing. Even if this takes place over the next couple of weeks, Grant Thornton's first move will be to call a creditors' meeting to see who is owed money. Whether this can be done before Christmas is anyone's guess.

Then it will have to investigate what money is available, and decide the best course. If that is to wind up the company and distribute any assets, it could take between 28 and 48 days to get a wind-up order. Roll on a merry new year.



The full article contains 817 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Gia,

London 16/11/2008 12:32:09
Dear Teresa Hunter,

if you had "never heard of this virtual world for sad losers before reading the story", then I would suggest that your knowledge of virtual worlds is rather limited and needs updating before you get completely left behind. Let me help you by giving you a few resources and a tiny glimpse of what really goes on in virtual worlds:

http://www.ibm.com/3dworlds/businesscenter/us/en/
http://www.open.ac.uk/relive08/
http://www.rezed.org/
http://www.simteach.com
http://terranova.blogs.com/
http://www.fco.gov.uk/en/about-the-fco/publications/publications/pd-publication/web-2

Second Life has been around since 2003. We currently live in 2008; Second Life is hardly new. That aside, virtual worlds have existed and affected human relationships since their very early days in the 1970s. Numerous serious articles and books have been written about this topic, and it strikes me as odd that any earnest journalist would think of the divorce story as 'news' these days.

Do a little bit of research, Teresa, before you jump on the bandwagon of general ignorance. Here's a tip that I give to college students: when you do your research, please be critical and bear in mind that what is printed in newspapers or broadcast on TV and/or the radio is not always correct. Compare a variety of sources. It might be beneficial to communicate with an expert in the field or at least get in contact with someone who has direct first hand experience of the subject. - I for one would gladly share my virtual world insights with you!

Not doing thorough research on a topic can sometimes lead to very public embarrassment - but I am sure you know this already. You are an experienced journalist after all.

Thank you very much, Teresa, for giving me this opportunity to enlighten you and your readers by allowing me to expand on your views.

Kind regards,
Gia,
Second Life Education Community


PS:
Would it be very cynical of me to suspect that your references to Seco
2

Gia,

London 16/11/2008 12:35:21

PS:
Would it be very cynical of me to suspect that your references to Second Life, at least in part, were made because you hoped to increase the hit count on your article?
3

Dissector,

Stirling 18/11/2008 09:07:39
The observations about illusionary tax giveaways combined with smoke-n-mirrors are 100% correct. The devil will be in the detail and will probably provide the square root of nothing in terms of stimulus and higher taxes will follow - it's just a case of when not if.
New "entrepreneurial paradigms" have been 10-a-penny for the last 11 years - it's time for a significant and permanent simplification of the tax regime coupled with a loosening of the absurd state aid rules imposed by Brussels - the average Eurocrat's knowledge of business could be written on a pin head with space left over at the end.But they don't care as their remuneration and pensions are well protected by us - the taxpayers.
4

Hiri,

Scotland 18/11/2008 14:12:31
It's a common source of complaint by Print Journalists that newspapers are in decline due to the competition from new media, but if it cannot do better than Ms Hunter' level of ignorance then they really doesn't stand a chance. Let's look at this:

1. Firstly to have claim never to have heard a Second Life is just jaw-dropping. It's newsworthyness has declined somewhat of late, but in 2006 you couldn't move on the net without seeing a reference to it in any of the even vaguely tech sites.

2. Similarly stunning is an unfamiliarity with the ways social networks and phenomona work in the 21st Century such that she could even think that it would be the 'kiss of death'. Quite the reverse in fact - normally new registrations to SL run at around 11,000 a day, but in the wake of the story hitting the press they were hitting five to ten times that and are even now at double.

3. Lastly, but possibly the most important, this jibe about 'sad loosers'. It's quite common for people who feel threatened by new things to ridicule them, but generally they don't do it quite so publically, and more importantly to the very people who are going to support their jobs in future. Like it or not virtuality worlds in one form or another are here to stay and the 'sad loosers' you refer to are going to form a large proportion of the people who might buy your newspaper in future - or probably not buy if they're going to be insulted by a zeitgiest-challenged journalist such as you seem quite proud to be.

5

Evan Owen,

Uppergumtree 19/11/2008 07:34:33
Despite being glued to the web since er... well... must be around 1998, I have to admit to having never heard of Second Life either. Although I would agree that it sounds like a sad place to me too I must take a look before I declare that it should be renamed Getalife in case anyone fancies a punt at a defamation claim, if they have the money. As for being in the techie news two whole years ago I don't think that is something to be proud of, once it is old techie news it is er... a bit like all the other rapidly fading Internet stars or vitrual world concepts. Why do they need virtual worlds anyway? Sounds like a masked ball to me.

Right, why are we talking about a website when the economy is crashing down around our ears? Well I can see the clever connection Teresa made between two virtual worlds, without the two sad tales it would be hard to make a story out of Gordon Brown's twirling in 'phone booths to change to his international superhuman action hero 'personality' when all we see in UK Parliament and TV is a bit of a damp squib, soon to go the same way as dodgy websites and yesterday's concepts.

We need an action hero like we need a hole in the head and this crisis has the feel of a virtual world occupied by people who couldn't run a corner shop.
6

Freddy,

Edinburgh 19/11/2008 21:41:58
Second Life - Sad Life more like. Do all you second lifers not cope in the read world so you have to invent a new one? Why not channel your efforts into your real life and make a difference to this world instead of Pi$$ing about in a virtual life. Just get a real one!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.